God Bless The Economist

God Bless The Economist

For their review:

Imagine that you–or, if you prefer, a younger, more reckless version of you–committed a crime.
…
And say you were offered a choice: you could either spend those years behind bars, or you could get ten lashes.
…
You may think flogging is barbaric, but is there any question which you would choose if you could? According to Peter Moskos, a sociologist whose previous book, “Cop in the Hood”, detailed his year spent as a Baltimore beat cop: “If flogging were really worse than prison, nobody would choose it.”

The modern American prison system evolved as an alternative to flogging: penitentiaries were designed to “cure” prisoners of their criminality—to render them penitent—rehabilitating them into productive members of society. On this score, as on most others, it has failed.
…
“We build prisons for people we’re afraid of and fill them with people we’re mad at.”
…
Brutal and archaic it may be, but Mr Moskos convincingly argues that America’s prison system is at least as inhumane.
…
Perhaps the most damning evidence of the broken American prison system is that it makes a proposal to reinstate flogging appear almost reasonable. Almost.

Now will you buy my book?

FacebooktwitterlinkedinmailFacebooktwitterlinkedinmail

 

6 Responses

  1. JPP says:

    Are you interested in links to articles that fit within your blog's purview? I read certain stories and then wonder what your take would be. I didn't want to clog up your comments section. Two examples are:

    An app for recording police encounters, featured in the Atlantic

    theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/06/policing-the-police-the-apps-that-let-you-spy-on-the-cops/240916/

    and a pastor in Balt. starting an on-demand no-wait methadone clinic, featured in Balt Sun

    baltimoresun.com/health/bs-hs-methadone-clinic-20110623,0,1863752.story

  2. PCM says:

    I'm always interested.

    Feel free (as some people do) to send me an email with the link.

    mail@petermoskos.com

  3. Tim says:

    Link to the Economist review in the strangest of places:

    The Big Lead

  4. PCM says:

    Strange indeed. But then again, what could be a better sport?

  5. Anonymous says:

    I think flogging is great and we should start with Markos because he is guilty of being an asshole

  6. PCM says:

    Marcos was an asshole. And can you believe how many pairs of shoes his wife Imelda had? Insane. Definite candidate for flogging.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *